Pamela eisenbaum, harpersanfrancisco, 2009, 336 pp. While peter is prominent in the first part of acts, paul clearly dominates the latter portion of the book. Christian mythos teaches that saul, a rabbi, converted to christianity. Peter is to paul in acts what john the baptist is to jesus in the gospels. Yet his teachings stand in stark and overwhelming contradiction to those attributed to jesus.
Together, they help the alien escape from the fbi agents who are. An ala best book for young adults an ala notable childrens book an ira childrens book award winner named to 14 state award lists the book is a gem, of value to all ages, not just the young people to whom it is aimed. The following is a breakdown of the letters paul wrote and the possible timeframes in which he wrote them. The book paul was not a christian provides important background information about firstcentury judaism and wrestles with the question of pauls relationship to his jewish heritage.
He was a first century jew who represented a unique and emerging sect within judaism that became a separate religion later. Pamela eisenbaum, an expert on early christianity, reveals the true nature of the historical paul in paul was not a christian. In this book, paul focuses on the permanency of the new covenant 3, the ministry of reconciliation 5, 6, on christian giving 8, the call to be holy 67, and restoration and forgiveness of. In a nutshell, she argues against the common christian teaching about pauls life, which presents him starting out his adult career as a deadly jewish persecutor of christians. Paul was not a christian is a groundbreaking work that systematically overturns both scholarly and popular conceptions held by christians and jews, liberals and conservatives alike. This book is very highly recommended to both scholars and laypersons as all will gain from it. Hayess statement, that paul barely discussed jesus as a person, simply is not true. Paul is a 2011 science fiction road comedy film directed by greg mottola from a screenplay by simon pegg and nick frost.
For christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel. For example, norman geisler and thomas howe, in their book, when critics ask, reason in this fashion. Without buddha i could not be a christian by paul f. The historicity of the gospels the gospels were written by persons unknown not eyewitnesses. This book is not technical, but it is equally suitable for the student and for the.
Paul lived and died a jew that is the essential claim of this book. The primary point of her book is well made, paul was not a christian. These pillars of jewish faith complete submission to the scriptures, and hope in the messiah were essential dimensions of pauls christian outlooks. Acts 22 nlv paul tells of his past life paul bible. For example, paul leaves timothy in ephesus in 1 timothy 1. Her portrait of paul takes more than 250 pages to describe in her new book, paul was not a christian. This solution is a discussion hinging on pamela eisenbaums book entitled paul was not a christian. Without paul, the new testament would be radically different, if it had come into. Skeptics of the disputed letters hold several reasons for their disbelief. The new perspective on paul which has completely reoriented pauline studies over the last thirty years continues not only to inspire new theses, but to highlight still unresolved issues as well. Paul says the pharisees followed the law rigorously, but jesus says they were lax about the law paul says in philippians 3. Of course, as most of you know, i have not called myself a christian publicly for a very long time, twenty years or so i suppose. Outside of the book of revelation, the word mystery is used only one other time in the new testament, and not at all in the hebrew of the old testament, mark 4. Pamela eisenbaum, an expert on early christianity, reveals.
He played a crucial role in spreading the gospel to the gentiles nonjews during the first century, and his missionary journeys took him all throughout the roman empire. She explores the idea of paul not as the founder of a new christian religion, but as a devout jew who believed jesus was the christ who would unite jews and. The christian science monitor will keep readers engrossed from first page to last. Its very easy to come up with texts that show paul or one of the apostles as an evangelist, but not as simple to demonstrate that paul expected the early christian communities to evangelize. Paul did not see christianity as a replacement of judaism. Meyers preaches from the book of acts chapter 9 verses 1 thru 9, a passage known as. Here is what my new american standard bible says, acts 9. Thus, paul was not a christiana word that was in any case completely unknown to him because it had not yet been invented. First, they claim that the history presented in the disputed letters do not match what one finds in the book of acts. Paul was not a christian pamela eisenbaum paperback. Are there any churches that do not accept the teachings of. First, the physical appearance of christ, and matters relating to his family, etc. Paul was not a christian is well worth careful reading.
It is also very true that paul needs to be read as a first century jew and that this context helps to elucidate the meaning of his writings. Paul was not a christian a book by pamela eisenbaum. Scholars have debated whether or not hebrews was written by paul. Pamela eisenbaum, a n expert on early christianity, reveals the true nature of the historical paul in paul was not a christian. The new perspective on paul which has completely reoriented pauline. She explores the idea of paul not as the founder of a new christian. Through revelation paul reveals to us the mysteries of god, yahushua, wisdom, and the faith, romans 16. For 30 years, he taught undergraduates at xavier university in cincinnati. The original message of a misunderstood apostle eisenbaum, pamela new york. Author and recovering nice guy paul coughlin points the way for all men who yearn to live a life of boldness and conviction like jesus as he discusses his latest book, no more christian. Pamela michelle eisenbaum reveals the historical paul, not as the founder of a new christian religion, but as a devout jew who believed jesus was the christ who would unite. The western tradition by david nirenberg, but without the picture of paul as one who. These writings appear to be based on sources and traditions derived from christian jews from jerusalem who fled to pella a city in the decapolis on the eastern side of the jordan river around the time of the destruction of. Knitter is the paul tillich professor of theology, world religions and culture at union theological seminary in new york and the author of many books including the myth of religious superiority.
Acts 22 new life version nlv paul tells of his past life. They were jews who believed in jesus, but did not proclaim their religious identity as christians. First, with respect to the book that stands at the foundation of the christian religion, the new testament. I was born in the city of tarsus in the country of cilicia. Paul originally saul of tarsus was the brilliantlysuccessful missionary who transformed the fledgling sect of christians into a movement that spread throughout the known world.
As eisenbaum reveals, paul is not the true founder of christianity as is often claimed, nor does paul understand jesus christ as having. It was athanasius, the bishop of alexandria, who listed the books of the new testament and. Paul started more than a dozen churches, and hes traditionally considered the. Rather, he believed that christianity was the branch of judaism which recognized that jesus was the true messiah. According to eisenbaum, although paul believed in jesus christ, this. Read paul was not a christian online by pamela eisenbaum books. Knitter, author of without buddha i could not be a christian, is paul tillich professor of theology, world religions and culture at union theological seminary in new york city.
The apostle paul was one of the most influential leaders of the early christian church. The tradition of christianity turned paul into a christian long after he passed away, but it. She explores the idea of paul not as the founder of a new christian religion, but as a devout jew who believed jesus was the christ who would unite jews and gentiles and fulfill gods universal plan for humanity. The problem with this book is that it was very predictable and unbelievable. The paul page blog archive paul was not a christian. The book of acts portrays a very interesting relationship between peter and paul. As eisenbaum reveals, paul is not the true founder of christianity. It is a serious and very clear exposition of what changed and what stayed the same in pauls religious life. Finally there is a book for the nonspecialist that challenges this overwhelming consensus. In this final analysis of paul was not a christian it is important to keep in mind that pamela eisenbaum is also not a christian and as eisenbaums premise is that paul was a jew through and through, it is important to keep in mind that pamela eisenbaum is also a jew through and through. The pseudoclementine writings of the late fourth century take up and develop the tensions between james and paul. The drama of a novel meets scholarship in leading christian biographer john pollocks classic work about one of the most transforming persons in history. The apostle masterfully combines careful adherence to biblical text, detailed research, and a storytellers gift to create a book equally relevant for both casual readers.
Because so many of the early christians came by way of paul, and because so much of it is interpreted through his prolific. He started out as a catholic priest but left in order to marry in 1982. Thats why plummers book pauls understanding of the churchs mission is such an important book. First, if you mean outright removal from the canon, as in the jefferson bible, no large denominational body has done so that i am aware of secondly, since paul wrote half the new testament, he is the source of many of our doctrinal writings about items from the nature of salvation to sexual ethics. I have to say i love the christmas box, so i am not necessarily anti richard paul evans. Antijudaism did not start with the first people to misunderstand paul the book to read is antijudaism. From the first chapter, i had some parts of the story figured out. This essay was originally published for the atlanta freethought society in 2000. Why i am not a christian i just now fifteen minutes ago came to realize with the most crystal clarity i have ever had why i cannot call myself a christian. Eisenbaum shows the implausibility of the common interpretation of paul that pits a christian essence against a superficial or rejected jewish hull. Did paul write all thirteen letters attributed to him. In fact, that is utter fallacy to support false doctrinetheology. Two billion christians still read the 2,000yearold letters of paul as spiritual guidance for daily living.
474 1126 1019 1335 1277 857 825 1251 926 114 1480 20 1515 390 1600 1327 1271 896 341 417 1017 147 245 549 1406 1302 920 734 454 488 135 1417 1486 1087 397 1341 1072 1466 1465 693 29 819